Reflections on art and architecture by TIME critic Richard Lacayo.

Antiquities OPEC?

Greece and Italy have taken a step towards joint action in the smuggle struggle — the fight to regain illegally exported antiquities. (via) Greek Minister of Culture Mihalis Liapis was in Rome this week to meet with his Italian counterpart Sandro Bondi to discuss ways to coordinate efforts for the return of looted work.

For now it's not clear what their joint ventures will amount to. Somewhat garbled press reports mention technical cooperation between Greek and Italian law enforcement. But as more "source nations" reach out to one another to cooperate on this issue, Derek Fincham, on his Illicit Cultural Property blog, is wondering about the eventual possibility of what he calls "an antiquities OPEC". I'm not sure the analogy holds — OPEC is powerful because it sits on top of a natural resource that, at the end of the day, the world requires. Antiquities source nations have.....antiquities.

But as I read Fincham's post this morning I was reminded that last fall, when I was working on a lengthy Time story about the fight over antiquities, Zahi Hawass, the head of Egypt's Supreme Council of Antiquities and one of the most visible figures in this fight, mentioned in an e-mail that he hoped to organize an international meeting of source nations this year. But I haven't seen any further news on that idea.

What is clear is that in the aftermath of the success that the previous Italian Culture Minister Francesco Rutelli had in his campaign to bring ancient objects back to Italy, Greece has been stepping up its own efforts. Earlier this month the Greek government announced that the important American collector Shelby White would be returning two disputed objects from her collection. (Which the Greek Culture Ministry specified that she had acquired "in good faith".) In January White, a major benefactor of the Metropolitan Museum in New York, also returned ten objects to Italy.

And of course, when the New Acropolis Museum in Athens finally has its official opening later this year, Greece will ramp up its campaign for the return of the Elgin Marbles from Britain. I wonder if there's any way for Italy to cooperate with that?

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (1)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    Yes, this is interesting, the notion of Antiquities OPEC. If the collaboration among and a deliberation at international level of the source nations do materialize, it will certainly be the best piece of news for world cultural property this year.

    As it is, Shelly White has returned 10 antique artifacts to Italy and intends to give back two to Greece. I could be least certain if other global collectors (either in their own personal capacity or on behalf of museums) would do exactly likewise.

    Britain appears to have accumulated a vast number of foreign antiquities during the past several centuries, notably from ancient civilizations like China, Egypt and India. If even part of these were to be returned in good faith to the source nations, the British Museum would likely to be half empty.
    (Tan Boon Tee)

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Looking Around Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's Looking Around in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
KHAN MOHAMAD, an Afghan farmer who does not support the U.S. presence in Afghanistan and has fled his hometown; many Afghans think Americans should negotiate with the Taliban instead of fighting against them

Stay Connected with TIME.com