-
ADD TIME NEWS
- NEWSLETTERS
Anguished Architect Alert
This morning the British daily The Guardian published a feature piece on Rem Koolhaas in which the oracular architect had this to say:
"The market economy thrives on spectacle and novelty," says Koolhaas. "Its buildings are ever more dramatic. It offers the promise of total freedom, but in architecture this quickly leads to the danger of grotesqueness. It is hard to do serious, disciplined buildings in such a condition. The media, of course, encourages this teenage architecture; it gives most attention to extreme capitalist buildings, to this ever-growing accumulation of architectural extravagance, to fanciful museums full of shops.
I have to agree with Koolhaas about the danger of the grotesque, of clients urging their architects, including mediocre ones — I don't mean Koolhaas — to produce ever more flamboyant buildings as a way to get noticed. (I've been told that something of the kind played a role in Frank Gehry's over the top design for the Experience Music Project in Seattle, an undertaking by Microsoft billionaire Paul Allen and his sister.) But for Koolhaas to complain about the media giving attention to the "ever-growing accumulation of architectural extravagance" seems a bit odd coming from the man whose firm designed the rather extravagant and heavily publicized Seattle Public Library...

to say nothing of the forthcoming CCTV Headquarters in Beijing.

I guess he must mean all those other extravagant buildings. You know, the ones the other guys do.
-
1
That's probably exactly what he does mean, and if you look at his firm's approach to design and contrast it with Libeskind's (which is to contrast elaborate statistical and structural studies with poetic devices like symbolism, metaphor, and affect, and a complete disinterest in any of the traditional functional roles of architecture) the distinction he makes here would be much easier to comprehend. Instead, you judge here simply by juxtaposing images, which is no way to discuss architecture.
Most Popular »
- Palin on Oprah: Can You See the Real Me?
- Curb Watch: Seinfeld 2.0
- The Bishops' Line in the Sand
- Motorola DROID review (Verizon Wireless)
- Cell-Phone Bills: Even Economists Can't Make Sense of Them
- 'Expert' Wine Sippers Take Us All for Suckers
- Doug Hoffman Tell Glenn Beck He's Hoping for Miracle
- IA Poll: Culver Far Behind In Battle Of Govs
- Palin Was Against SNL Before She Was For It
- 20 Money-Saving iPhone Apps
- Five Things the U.S. Can Learn from China
- China: Two Die After Swine Flu H1N1 Vaccine
- Obama in Asia: Five Things the U.S. and China Agree On
- How a Bank Robber Became an Antihero in France
- Happiness Paradox: Why Are Americans So Cheery?
- Spain: Teen Masturbation Sex Ed Workshops Spark Outrage
- Manny Pacquiao vs. Cotto: Filipino Phenom Wins by TKO
- Obama China Town Hall: Select Audience, Easy Questions
- Forgotten Australians Remembered by PM Kevin Rudd
- The Meaning and Mythos of Manny Pacquiao













RSS